Showing posts with label Modernization Is A Lie. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Modernization Is A Lie. Show all posts

Tuesday, September 5, 2017

So I Went to the Pretty New State Store...

I went to one of the new State Stores. You know the ones, with a new color palette that supposedly offers a warm, welcoming atmosphere for consumers to browse the limited selection. I wandered over to what they call the focal point of the store; a new table, where customers can find staff to answer questions or provide recommendations. Just what I was looking for. 

I waited for somebody to come over to the table.
And waited for somebody to come over to the table.
And waited for somebody to come over to the table.

Did I mention that the table was the focal point of the store?
Looks kinda empty

Ah, a wine person! They wandered over and asked if they could help.
I said, I don't know. I have some questions.
"So what are you looking for?"

Answers.
"I'll do my best, what's the first thing on your list?"

Can you name one thing that has decreased in price in the past few months?
"Sure, pints of Nikolai vodka. We have a guy that comes in everyday, well, actually we have a few,  and is so pleased that happened.  Probably our happiest customer."

Anything go up that you noticed?
"A few here and there but when the wave of 400+ hits next month I'm sure I'll see a bunch of them"

Since this store was remodeled in the same location, did any increase in products on the shelf come with the remodel?
"Oh no, with the wider aisles, this table stuck in the middle and the plants and all there are less things in the store now then there was before."
Style over substance eh?
"I can't say."
So how long were you closed for the remodel?
"About 3 months."
Doesn't that seem like a long time to be closed? Didn't the Dollar Store close for like 16 days when they remodeled?
"The Dollar Store isn't run by the PLCB."

So is this 'modernization' thing working out, or should the Legislature have gone for more privatization?
"We aren't allowed to talk about privatization"
You aren't allowed to have an opinion?
"We can have an opinion, we just aren't allowed to talk about it."
So, the powers that be in Harrisburg don't have enough faith in you workers to offer a reasonable explanation why State Stores should still exist.
"Could be but I can't talk about it."

Can I ask if you belong to the union or just pay fair share?
"I just pay fair share, most of the people in this store just pay fair share. We have too, not like there is a choice."
So how long have you been here?
"I started as a Seasonal 6 years ago, worked part time while I was in school."
Do you think of this as a career after all that time?
"No way, I'm going to an online school for my Masters. Once I have that and a job lined up where I don't have to wear an apron, I'll let somebody else take this spot."
Maybe then you can talk to me about privatization.
"Yeah, maybe then, ha ha."
I can't talk about Privatization, the PLCB doesn't trust me.

What do you say when people tell you they bought ...whatever for less in Maryland, Delaware, New Jersey, Florida or wherever?
"I'm sure it is true sometimes but those chain stores or Mom & Pops don't have to have a store in Nowheresville, PA like we do. We have to support that somehow"
Why? Don't you think a grocery store would carry the basics if they could?
"You're talking about privatization again, so I can't comment."

The conversation above is semi-fictional. It didn't happen with just one clerk, but every question and answer did happen with multiple clerks over the past six months. I wish I could get managers to answer as truthfully as some of their workers, but they drink the Kool-Aid every day, and won't stand for it.

Monday, April 24, 2017

Reality check: how is "modernization" working out?

The end of February marked eight months gone of the fiscal year, and just under seven months of Act 39's "modernization" of the state's police-enforced monopoly on wine and liquor sales, changes that Governor Wolf trumpeted as "historic."

So things are booming for the State Stores now, right? Well...not exactly.

Remember how bailment was going to cut inventory costs and save the citizens all sorts of money? It may have but it didn't last. Inventory cost went up over 10% so far this year and has now gone up over 46% since bailment was implemented in 2012. It will certainly pass pre-bailment amounts next year with a modest 3% increase. For the same period of time, the inflation rate went up 6.2%. (2012 Inventory $175,902,668; 2017 Inventory (so far) $257,285,382; Pre-bailment inventory $265,816,891)

Still, with all that inventory they must be making more money right? Sorry! Total Operating Income is down almost 5% year to date, while total assets squeaked out a gain of 4.2%. Meanwhile, Total Liabilities jumped almost 16%, from $803.7 million to 930.5 million. (And you know who has to cover that; you and me, the taxpayers.) Total debt is up almost $50 million more than at this time last year; $264,454,330 or about $26 million in additional debt than at the end of last fiscal year. To be fair, the PLCB statement has numerous notations about 'See Note X, Table Y', but they don't provide what those notes are. Are they valid reasons, or just lame excuses? The public doesn't know, and the PLCB clearly doesn't think we need to; it's kind of like their selection, if they don't have it, we don't need it.

The Never-Ending PLCB Story!
The PLCB is selling more product while making less money. In desperation, they're dipping into reserves to make a big payment to try and fend off  privatization, blowing smoke as thick as possible so you don't notice that they're going even further in the hole with liabilities approaching a Billion dollars...all the while remaining as incompetent as ever.

The benefits of modernization? I'm not seeing any evidence of that extra $137 million the Governor said they would make, and I'm willing to bet I won't, with only four months left in the fiscal year.

How many reasons do you need to get rid of this broken system and replace it with one that works for the consumer?

Monday, March 27, 2017

The numbers don't lie...but somebody is

In the House Appropriations Budget Meeting for the PLCB held earlier this month, the PLCB leadership said that they would have to dip into reserves to meet the Governor's anticipated request for $185 million. Why is that, if "modernization" is going to be the windfall that the Governor (and clerks' union president Wendell W. Young IV) says it is? Are their arguments that facile?

The Governor said in his "Budget In Brief" of 02/07/17 (pg.15) that through modernization ..."an additional $137 million in LCB revenues will be generated." The PLCB didn't correct or disagree with that number. So let's see what doesn't add up. If their income for FY 2015-16 — after paying for the BLCE, but before the General Fund Transfer — was $103,856,933 (which it was, according to their financial report), then a $137 million increase would take it to just over $240 million. But if the PLCB has to dip into reserves to pay $185 million, that has to mean that their so-called "profit" is less than $185 million.
OH NO!  42 million of my friends are missing!
However, during that same budget meeting — in sworn testimony — the PLCB said that even with record sales again, they would only make about $90 million for FY 17-18. That $90 million and $137 million "modernization bonus" take it to $227 million in total. That's $42 million more than the $185 million they said they could pay IF they dipped into reserves. So where is this $42+ million going? If they make the $90 million they project, and the $137 million additional that they didn't object to, then turning in $185 million to the General Fund should be no problem. Remember that these numbers are what the PLCB calls "profit," so everything (except the $238 million in pension debt...but that's another story) is already covered.

We have to ask: why after all the "modernization" is in place does the PLCB think they are actually going to make LESS than they did in FY 15-16?

Could it be that "modernization" is a sham, and that it isn't going to bring $137 million, or $100 million, or even $80 million? Is being off by well over 60% how the Governor and the PLCB do estimates? How big a failure is this going to be? The MINIMUM $42 million off would push this well beyond wine kiosk failure, or the 66% computer cost overrun, or selling house brands or anything I can think of. This would be a failure the size of the 82 year lie that the State Stores would be convenient to the public. They got what they wanted, "flexible pricing" and all, so show us the modernization money, PLCB!

Do the math and decide: are they just stupid? Or is the PLCB deliberately misrepresenting how much money they will bring in for the Commonwealth?

Tuesday, January 10, 2017

This will only hurt a little bit, we're just flexible pricing.

On January 1st, the PLCB raised the price of 341 bottles of Booker's Bourbon from $59 to $99.99, a 66% increase. Bottles that they already had in stock on the shelves across the state. Bottles that they had already bought and paid for at a lower price. This was in anticipation of the published March or April price increase by Jim Beam on NEW product.

However, Beam didn't increase the price to $99.99 due to consumer pressure and outrage, They decided that an increase to $69.99 would be enough at the moment, and changed their minds before the actual price increase took effect. So how come the PLCB price went to $99.99 anyway? (Update: the PLCB has belatedly lowered the price to $69.99...but you are still paying more for bottles they bought at a lower price.)

The PLCB excuse was that they raised the price for Booker’s to $99.99 on January 1 “at the request of the vendor,” according to PLCB spokesman Shawn Kelly. I'd like to see that in writing. Remember: Beam gets no benefit from an immediate price increase, so what the PLCB is saying is that Beam told them, 'Hey, fine. Screw your citizens by raising the price across the board, limiting sales and competitive pricing of our product so you can make more money in your little monopoly.'

There are two factors at work here, a desperate desire to maximize 'profit,' and lack of any consumer protection and overwatch. The PLCB used to brag about how they controlled price increases, saying that industry instituted more increases then they had, but now increases are seen as a way to make more money for the state by gouging the consumer.

How does that work? Say Bottle "A" sold on the shelf for $25 before "Flexible Pricing;" the PLCB paid about $14.50 for it before all the taxes, fees, markups and rounding they add. Now, with "flexible pricing," the bureaucrats decide to negotiate to try and save themselves some of that money. (Negotiating is something they could have been doing all along when it would have benefited the consumer, but they chose not to. But now it benefits the PLCB, so full speed ahead, boys!)

Back to the example. The PLCB knows that another state's monopoly system only pays around $12.30 for the same bottle. They've known for decades that other states pay less, and decided not to do anything about it. There was a conscious decision that having a lower price yet selling more product to increase overall sales was not something the PLCB wanted to do. Too much work selling that extra amount of product for that sales increase, apparently. Yet, keeping the same price, selling the same amount, and gouging the consumer by not passing any savings along when producers offered deals was decided to be perfectly acceptable.

The PLCB now manages to get $1.50 shaved off of the wholesale price. To make sure that the same amount of taxes are collected, they increase the markup from what used to be a standard 30% to nearly 47% to reach the same point to apply the 18% Johnstown Flood Tax. The consumer sees NONE of the price reduction from the agency's "buying power." The state doesn't collect any more taxes, but the PLCB gets to say they are making more money, and they cover their ballooning operating expenses for another few years. Remember: the amount the state gets by having the PLCB in the middle is less than they would get if taxes were raised by the same amount. The cost to the consumer is the same. In other words, we get to pay more to keep the PLCB jobs program afloat.

Here's another example of the "benefit" of flexible pricing: sale items. The PLCB itself doesn't put anything on sale, other than closeouts (of items they can't be bothered to sell), and out of season items ,like the Christmas gift packs that are on sale now. Everything else that you see a sale tag on is a reduction from the producer. Formerly, the PLCB had to pass on those reductions to the consumer; that was the law (and a good law to keep a monopoly in check). What they can do now is "recapture" some of that savings that was supposed to go to you, the consumer, through the magic of "flexible pricing."

Here's how that works. Suppose a distillery offers a $5.00 off special to the PLCB. Used to be that the PLCB approved the sale, printed up sale tags, and the citizens got to pay closer to what some other places charge. But under the new "modernization" law, "flexible pricing" allows the PLCB to decide that they don't want the citizens to have $5.00 off, that $3.00 off is good enough ("Good enough" should be their agency-wide motto), so they take the full $5.00 discount from the producer, print up sale tags for $3.00 off, and they keep the other $2.00 - such a deal! Doesn't that make you feel good about "modernization"? Don't you wonder what rat hole your two bucks is going down?

PLCB apologists will point out that private business can and does do the same thing. Sure, they can, but there is one thing that keeps that in check: competition from other businesses. If you decide to keep that extra $2.00, but your competition down the street (remember, private liquor sales means a "alcohol on every street corner") doesn't, and guess who will have more sales? But pass on some of that wholesale price reduction to your customers, and who will have more repeat business?

This is the heart of it. The total lack of competition in Pennsylvania is why we pay more, why we have less convenience, why we have less selection, and why we don't have the same protection from price gouging the free market provides. Don't like what the State Store System has, at the price they charge? Screw you, you have no choice. But if you're in a free state, and you don't like what Bob's Liquor has at the price they charge? You can just go somewhere else where the selection or prices are better.

This lack of choice will always make the citizens serve the needs of the PLCB  instead of them serving the needs of the citizens.

Monday, November 21, 2016

PLCB lies of omission

Sounds like the PLCB to me.
People — or government agencies — don't always tell the truth when their jobs are on the line. Such is the case all too frequently with the management of the PLCB. From the former CEO telling the workers to destroy wine kiosk paperwork, to a different CEO not knowing who came up with the idea to spend millions on anti-Pennsylvania "house brands." 

Now we have the lie of omission from the Board. After years of meetings with the House Appropriations Committee, the Senate Appropriations Committee, the Senate Law and Justice Committee, and others, not once, not ever did they say that "modernization" won't reach the goals that their supporters in the legislature said it would, specifically the $65 (or even $50) million that the Legislature estimated.

Until now
, that is.

I'll save you the click, and give you the nut:
"[PLCB director of communications Elizabeth] Brassell says she cannot speak to the specific $65 million figure because it did not come from the PLCB. The number came from a House fiscal analysis in June. A House Appropriations Committee report last month pegged that number at a slightly more conservative $50 million in 2016/17.
“I’m not sure what/when fiscal analyses came from different folks or what may have changed. Sorry, can’t speak for data or assumptions that aren’t ours,” Brassell said. “We have yet to be able to meaningfully estimate how much additional revenue might come from flexible pricing, but it’s certainly not the estimates attributed to Act 39 as a whole.”
Did you notice that she didn't say what the PLCB thought it would be? Another omission designed to keep the "owners" — you and I — in the dark. Why would they do this? Because if they didn't agree and the figure is is much lower, as it appears it will be, then "modernization" would be shown to be the failure that it is. And why not? The recent history of the PLCB is full of schemes that were supposed to make money that never panned out: the bailment scheme, the new POS system, the SLO system, closing stores and reopening them (well, someone's cousin the real estate agent probably DID make money on those deals, right?).
More PLCB excuses.
I didn't say that. I didn't say anything!
Disingenuous? Most certainly. Illegal? Probably not, but should we expect more from the people that run OUR business? Shouldn't we hold public servants to a higher standard because what they do or didn't do affects the entire state? You know who pays the price for these lies isn't the PLCB. It's us, the public that has to put up with more lipstick on the PLCB pig.

After all that has supposedly changed in the past year...can you buy a six-pack of beer, a case of another beer, a bottle of wine, and a bottle of liquor in one place? Nope. Can you buy wine in grocery stores? Not really; the huge majority don't and won't have a license because of the inane "cafe" requirements. Can you find the selection that you see in other states, and on the shelf, not in their "online store," something you can look at buy right now? Not even close: there are private stores that stock on the shelves as many items  as the PLCB carries on their imaginary stocklists.

We deserve better and the free market provides it; the PLCB never will be able to.

Monday, October 24, 2016

"Flexible pricing" means someone's getting screwed again

Is four bottles of wine worth the screwing we're going to get from flexible pricing?

Oh, my pricing is flexible. You bet, Slick.
Ever since the State Store clerk's union and its president (Wendell W. "Windy Wendy" Young IV), the Democrats who do their bidding in the Legislature (yeah, they do, and if there's a Democratic legislator who can give me a real reason for keeping the State Stores other than "it gets me lots of campaign cash from the unions," they'll be the first one), and syndicalist economists put forth their plans for the "modernization" of the police-enforced monopoly of the PLCB, one thing has been the hidden poison in the sweet candy of concessions, the coiled and sharpened spring waiting to slash out of the intricately-ticking machinery of "improvement" and slice open our wallets — "Flexible pricing."

Whenever the laundry list of proposals came out — more stores open on Sundays, open later, hiring outside Civil Service rules (so they could hire some less dead wood) — flexible pricing was always there, about five or six bullets down the list, promising to break prices free of the mandated mark-up so that they could give us lower prices! Except it didn't say "lower pricing," it said "flexible pricing," and we told you over and over again, "flexible pricing," in the PLCB's control, was only going to "flex" in one direction: UP. 

Well, they got it, when Senator McIlhinney laid his latest mutated liquor bill on us, and Speaker Turzai signed off on it (there were some good things in there, but whether they were worth the cost...), and The Wolf Who Walks Like A Man signed it. Hurray! Free at last...a little!

Remember: Wendy said to look concerned.
But... Flexible pricing, guys! Hot damn!
And Wendell cried and pounded the podium, and told us that allowing supermarkets to sell wine was the beginning of the end, death by a thousand cuts...but he must have been smiling as he turned away from the cameras, a secret, villainous smile, because the PLCB and the union got the flexible pricing they wanted. It was limited to the 150 best-selling products (which is where most of the money comes from anyway), and it cost them a tiny little slice of their monopoly, allowing licensees to sell no more than four bottles of wine at a time (at prices guaranteed to be higher than the State Stores, because they had to be bought from the PLCB wholesale monopoly at rigged prices). 

But it was worth it to Wendell and his yellow-shirted minions in the PLCB. Now journalists across the state are finally waking up to what we told you years ago: flexible pricing means we're getting screwed. Again. The PLCB is finally using their long-heralded buying power to hammer down the price to them, but you'll never see a dime of that. Have a look. 
The Pittsburgh TribLIVE, October 5th: "Pa. LCB accused of using new 'flexible pricing' law to boost profits" — "Privately, though, wine and spirits officials said the LCB asked for specific percentage cuts in cost but without saying what markup would then be applied. That strategy means suppliers wouldn't know what the final shelf price would be for shoppers." 
Harrisburg PennLIVE, October 19: "Lawmakers need to go back and include liquor in 'liquor reform'" — "We urge the state to forego what it euphemistically calls "flexible pricing" for another two years. We urge the General Assembly to finish the job and complete privatization." 
Harrisburg PennLIVE, October 18 — "Here's how Pennsylvanians got hoodwinked by booze 'modernization'" — "The provision, known as flexible pricing, isn't likely to be very satisfying to anyone who shops for wine or spirits in Pennsylvania. It gives the Pennsylvania Liquor Control Board (PLCB) the ability to manipulate price, something it has long desired as a way of raising revenues." 
Pittsburgh Post-Gazette October 20 — "Pennsylvania's liquor ‘modernization’ hoax" — "Here’s an unfortunate reality about Pennsylvania’s so-called modernization of its liquor business: You’re going to pay a lot more for it. This isn’t modernization, but rather a step backward."
What does Windy Wendy offer in rebuttal? This almost incoherent mish-mash of his old arguments — the State Stores offer competitive prices (Really? How can they be "competitive" when there is, by law, no competition allowed?), they bring in lots of taxes (just like private stores would), and the new licensees will not match the selection or prices of the PLCB (that's actually true: because the law doesn't allow them to) — with a pathetic plea to 'stop picking on me': "Is it time for PennLive to perhaps take a different tack on the long-running battle over dismantling the Pennsylvania Liquor Control Board (PLCB) by, perhaps giving it a rest already?" Perhaps perhaps! He's so pissed he can't even speak straight; this is a direct quote from the op-ed piece that PennLIVE allowed him to dump on their website: "We opposed this law, Act 39, will cost taxpayers millions in lost revenue." [SIC] Sad, really. He's clearly got nothing, and his Democratic lapdogs in the Legislature have got nothing. 

Okay, headline...I got it!
"McIlhinney's Mistake Screws Us All"
So let's do something about this. "Flexible pricing" was foisted on us by Senator Chuck McIlhinney, for reasons known mainly to him. Why don't the newspapers ask McIlhinney why the PLCB got this one-sided tool without any restrictions on its use, or requirements for reporting on how it is used? Ask him why there's a four-bottle limit on wine sales at licensees? How about you ask him why his law favors big markets over mom-and-pop stores by requiring the whole separate "cafe" with separate registers and clerks to ring up beer and wine? Ask McIlhinney who he's compromising with. And ask the Democrats why not ONE of them has voted for real liquor privatization.

And the rest of us? The citizens? Ask your legislators, your reps and your senators, to put a two-year hold on "flexible pricing." Haven't we paid enough? Why should we pay more so the PLCB can continue to paper over the ruin that their spiraling operating costs are creating?

The best solution to all of this? Stop tinkering: PRIVATIZE. It works in over 2/3 of the other states, it works in over 85% of the countries in the world. Why not Pennsylvania? 

Tuesday, April 19, 2016

Numbers, numbers, numbers

Numbers you won't see in the PLCB Annual Report

A look at some State Store numbers that are always missing in the PLCB's annual report.

1.) The average amount of non-tax revenue returned to the state per unit (single bottle or box) of wine or liquor - 73 cents

2.) Not counting the actual cost of the item, what PA spends to put one item on the shelf - $3.06

3.) What PA spends to put an item on the shelf, including the average cost of the item - $11.40

4.) What it costs with taxes to put one average item on the shelf - $15.21

5.) Average rental cost per store (2015) - $1432 a week

6.) Industry average profit margin 8.1%; PLCB 2015 profit margin 6%

7.) PLCB Effective markup, not counting any taxes - 45.36%

8.) U.S. state and federal government workers average benefits as percentage of salary - 36.4%.
PLCB benefits as percentage of salary - 85-104% (as stated by Board members during the Appropriations hearings in the Senate).

9.) Percent of sales actually checked for proof of age - under 2%

10.) Retail Wine Specialists as a percentage of workers: 1.7%

11.) Retail Wine Specialist as a percentage of TotalWine employees - ~20%


The Proof

1. - $80M returned to General Fund plus $25M for BLCE plus $5M alcohol Awareness plus $1.7M for Drug & Alcohol programs divided by 153.5 million unit sales We are told "Modernization" will increase profits by $180M At 73 cents a bottle...well, you do the math. (Keep in mind that the $80 million is a very flexible number, mostly representing what the Legislature requires from the PLCB, whether it's actually "profit" or not.)
2. - Operating Expenses (minus the cost of wine and spirits) of $470M, divided by units sold. The lower this number, the more efficient the organization is. It has never gone down for the PLCB.
3. - Operating Expenses $1.751B divided by units sold 153.5M. Since the PLCB doesn't negotiate prices on the majority of items, this cost is higher than it should be too.
4, - Gross sales ($2,335B) divided by total units sold. $3.81 for every bottle or box sold is the average sales and Johnstown Flood Tax; more expensive bottles can be much more.
5. - Rental expense for all operating leases $44.9M divided by 603 stores. Of course, this cost will increase as the PLCB tries to move into higher traffic areas.
6. - IBISWorld, May 2013, Operating Income divided by Sales Net of Taxes. With increased pension costs, workers comp, salary, and benefits increasing, this won't improve any time soon.
7. - COGS divided by gross profit. The 30% markup you hear about is only one of the many fees and adjustments made to the price. This fat markup of 45.36% still wasn't going to be enough to cover increasing operating costs, according to August Hehemann, the PLCB's Director of Finance, who last year advised the Board to raise it 5% more. The Board, for once in tune to the politics of privatization, decided against that.
8. - US Dept Of Labor - Bureau of Labor Statistics, 2016 PA Senate Appropriations hearing. Nice gig if you can get it, but does it provide any benefit to the consumer?
9. - 1.3M cardings divided by 65.5M transactions You have slightly better than 98% chance of not being carded (that's a 0.0% chance at private stores like Wegmans), and since the State Stores are never checked by police for underage compliance...how effective are they?
10. - 4654 (3/15/2016) divided by 81 (www.pennwatch) There appears to be no Spirits Specialists in the PLCB.
11. - 5000 employees and 800 Wine Specialists (Total Wine wiki ). Look at it this way: the PLCB has ONE retail wine specialist for every 7.4 stores, Total has SIX at each store.

Friday, January 1, 2016

Liquor Privatization's Enemy #1: Senator Charles McIlhinney


Three times in three years a reasonably effective liquor privatization bill passed the PA House (it also came close in 2014, but got sidetracked as GOP legislators scurried to distance themselves from Governor Corbett's sinking reelection ship). That's something that never happened before in the 80-odd years since the PLCB was established, despite decades of polls that consistently showed that was what Pennsylvanians wanted. But thanks to the solid support and unfailing energy of Representative Mike Turzai, the House Majority Leader and now Speaker, it finally happened, and it was historic.

One of those bills also passed the Senate, but it was a sacrificial lamb, vetoed by Governor Tom "I Love Me Some PLCB" Wolf. But the other two were shot down in the Senate, practically single-handedly, by Senator Charles "Chuck" McIlhinney, the Republican who represents the 10th District in northern Bucks County...curiously, the same district that gave us Joe "Water Heater" Conti, better known to readers of the blog as Joe Da CEO, the former "CEO" of the PLCB who resigned three years ago while under investigation for ethics issues (an investigation that may still be going on under the eye of a federal grand jury). There must be something innately pro-PLCB about that area.

The first time the privatization bill passed the House, in 2013, McIlhinney held a press conference as soon as it happened -- in mid-March -- and announced that the Law & Justice Committee (his committee; he was and still is the majority chairman) would be holding hearings on liquor privatization. He had three months, and the hearings -- stacked with anti-privatization speakers, a circus of shouting and intimidation -- were shoved into the last part of that, after which McIlhinney held everything up on his committee until he presented his version of the bill.

Then I simply took the House language and burned it. With fire.
In a legislative move known as "gut and replace," McIlhinney replaced the House's bill in its entirety with his own scheme, a mishmash of State Store clerks' union-proposed "modernization" measures (that are blatantly anti-consumer), beer distributor pipe dreams, and his own plan for selling wine by the bottle (but only four bottles at a time) at taverns and restaurants, a plan no one asked for and no one wanted. The committee got that a week before the session was over. It never even came to a vote.

The second time, in 2015, the House passed another privatization bill. Knowing that Governor Tom "Look For The Union Label" Wolf would veto a solid liquor privatization bill in the first pass -- he'd said so, promised it -- McIlhinney waved it through, the Senate passed it, and sure enough: Wolf vetoed it, along with the proposed budget.

And now? We still have no budget, but McIlhinney's still at work. The House passed another privatization bill in December, part of their negotiation strategy with the Governor, and this time, McIlhinney went to work on it...making it look a LOT like the bill he shoved out in 2013, complete with no change to the state wholesale monopoly, nebulous talk about selling wine at grocery stores that had bought an R-license and were selling beer, and plenty of anti-consumer "modernization" language (including "flexible pricing," which essentially gives the PLCB the green light to raise prices to cover their ballooning operating expenses). It's what we've been calling The Big Step Sideways. It's not anything the House was going to pass when it comes back for reconciliation, and he knew it, and now liquor privatization has apparently been dropped from the negotiations. Chances are slim that it will come up this year; an election year. (Which is foolish: no legislator is going to lose their seat over how they vote on liquor privatization.)

Go ahead. Ask me "Why?" again. I love that.
McIlhinney, you've done it again. Which leads us to ask...why? As in Why does McIlhinney so doggedly and effectively thwart privatization efforts? He's a Republican, isn't he? Aren't they supposedly the party of business, of smaller government? Well...maybe. But there's pro-business, and then there's pro particular businesses; like this. And then there's the personal politics of the whole thing, like this. (It's worth noting that some pundits tag the beer magnate noted in those links, Pasquale "Pat" Deon," as the reason we didn't see a privatization bill pass the House in 2012). And then there's this winking tidbit about Pennsylvania politics: Unions buy Democrats; they rent Republicans.

But another why is this one: Why does the state Republican party continue to put up with McIlhinney's shenanigans on this issue, and indeed, why is he in the one spot, the chairmanship of Law & Justice, where he can effectively, single-handedly, block privatization? Is it true what the unions have consistently said, what the Democrats have consistently said? That the state GOP doesn't really want privatization, that it's too good an issue to run on, to get donations with, and to pass it would kill that cash source? The thing is, for that to be true, it would all hinge on...Chuck McIlhinney.


Monday, November 16, 2015

Wolf's Privatization Plan

"The state would still be running the system, but they would be leasing it out, That is privatization.” Jeffrey Sheridan, Governor Wolf’s press secretary.

Hired by the government, paid by the government, given offices by the government, but "that is privatization"? Wolfonomics is spreading! Now there are two people who are completely ignorant of economics over the past 200 years. Goes with the "Competition raises prices"  mantra the Governor tried to use when he vetoed the privatization bill.

This is the Wolf system in a nutshell:


Monday, November 9, 2015

Modernization won't do what the people want; Part V

This is just a reminder that what the PLCB says, and what the PLCB does are not always the same thing.

"Beginning January 2, 1934 and continuing as rapidly as alterations can be completed, 240 liquor stores will be open in Pennsylvania at convenient places to serve the public." (PLCB statement issued on the opening of the first 64 stores)

That statement, made almost 82 years ago, shows the failure of the entire State Store System. Is not making stores "convenient to the public" part of every modernization plan you have ever heard? They have been promising to do that since Day One and have failed miserably, especially considering that they have had over 80 years to complete the task.

Is having 25% fewer stores more convenient? Is stringing the public along for eight decades more convenient? Is having one or two stores in entire counties more convenient? Is having the PLCB at all more convenient?

Since the Liquor Code was created in 1951, the PLCB has had total non-legislative control over store size, store location, and hours of operation (except Sunday). If they wanted larger stores, they have had 64 years to lease them. If they wanted "more convenient" stores, they have had 64 years of total control of placement to do it. If they wanted to be open anytime from 7 a.m. to 2 a.m., they could do it. They have done none of it.

So don't believe me: believe the PLCB and ask yourself if they have managed to accomplish what they said they would do over the past 82 years?


Tuesday, October 27, 2015

A year later, and inventory is still mis-managed

Back in November of last year, the PLCB Annual Report said they had "...improved the product search feature of the Fine Wine & Good Spirits online store." (pg. 13). I pretty much proved that was BS at the time in my "After 80 years they still can't do inventory" story in January.

Here it is a year later, and you may be thinking, there might been some improvement. Maybe the PLCB has come up with some internal cooperation so that the database, retail stores, and website all know what is going on. If you believe that, well, I have a bridge to sell you.

Take the entry on the Fine Wine And Good Spirits  Facebook page of October 26th at 9 AM, where they tout having a coupon for the "new" (their words) Casa Noble Crystal Blanco tequila. If you want to find this item, you can go to one of two places to search it out, the Online Product Catalog or the "fancier" FWAGS website.

The Online Catalog lists Casa Noble Crystal Blanco tequila as an SLO item: you must buy a minimum of six bottles, at $43.79 each. Not a great deal even with a $3 coupon, considering it can be had for under $35 across the border. Going to the FWAGS webpage and doing a search for Casa Noble Crystal nets you  six listings in the Available Online section, none of which are actually Casa Noble products. Then there are 33 entries in the In Store section, which includes some wine cocktails even though it was a Spirits search. Of course, none of these are Casa Noble either. Finally we come to the 56 listings in the Available Special Order section. After fourteen items -- White Rum, Creme de Menthe, Captain Morgan, white whiskey, and Cognac -- comes the one and only listing for a Casa Noble Crystal, the last item on page one; it's still a 6 bottle SLO.

Is this their improvement after a YEAR of work? How much "modernization" of the search function should have we expected after the entire Board said they improved it back in November of last year? The answer is the same amount of improvement we can expect from any of the PLCB modernization schemes...little to none.


This just proves that there is little to no internal coordination in the PLCB.  The highly trained people who run the Facebook page don't know what the highly trained people who do the inventory call the same product and can't be bothered to find out, and the highly trained supervisors seem oblivious to the difference.

Is this any way to run a business? The answer is no, which is no shock: they aren't any kind of a business, just a poor excuse for the status quo.

PRIVATIZE!

Friday, September 18, 2015

Governor Wolf proposes liquor privatization compromise

DATELINE HARRISBURG:

Governor Wolf has proposed an historic liquor privatization compromise with Republicans. Patterned after Governor Corbett's extremely successful Lottery Privatization scheme, Wolf's proposal includes:
  • Keeping the PLCB wholesale and retail monopoly in place
  • Keeping and expanding the State Store System as a state jobs program
  • Increasing the number of State Store System workers
  • Keeping the same conflict of interest of the government selling and regulating alcohol
  • Keeping a single person or department who selects what the entire state is allowed to buy.
  • Adding another layer of fully-funded bureaucracy to the liquor system
  • Trading a state-controlled monopoly for another state-controlled monopoly (with a different name)
  • Dangling the possibility that this could someday maybe possibly somehow a long way off lead to wine at supermarkets and beer in convenience stores...in some manner
  • Other yet to be named and explained items

Some Republican leadership said they would have to study the proposal to figure out exactly what, if anything, this would change, or if the Governor was pulling another joke on them, like his trying to raise taxes by $4.7 Billion this year. Others simply refused to believe that this was a compromise and flatly rejected the notion as they should.

Stay tuned to this blog for further developments!

(Please note: we've added a new tag: "You've Got To Be Kidding." If Governor Wolf continues on his current path, it's going to see a lot of use; watch for it!)

Monday, August 24, 2015

The only number you need to know

Do  you want to know how crappy our State Store System is? All you need to know is this single fact. The number of States, Counties, or localities looking to move toward a system like the Pennsylvania liquor system:


NONE, NADA, NICHTS
Since the bad decisions made at the end of Prohibition, no state has ever shifted from a private free market system to a state-run liquor monopoly. Not once, not ever.

Our system is so good that nobody wants it. No one else believes in it except Utah, the only other state that is like us. Even they are somewhat better off since you can buy beer in grocery stores there! Alabama is looking to change, Montgomery County in Maryland, a "control county," has passed a partial privatization this year, Literally hundreds of towns in Texas alone have "gone wet" and even some here in PA, like Antrim Township.

The truth is that most people do not want to live under the quasi-prohibition model of the PLCB, be they in Pennsylvania or even under the more liberal versions found elsewhere. People want to be able to choose what they want and not what some bureaucrat in the capitol decides they should be allowed to have.

We don't want the corruption monopoly brings, either. Graft and corruption is not limited to the PLCB. North Carloina has its share too. Even 40 years ago there were charges and nothing really has changed since then. PA is no different. 5 senior members charged with graft, longstanding nepotism, junkets and "tastings" for members that have no qualifications to select mouthwash let alone wine for the entire state. 


Painting the PA liquor jail cell a nice bright color, putting up new drapes, and calling it "modernization" will not change the way the system works. The state charging more is no better than anybody else charging more, except that in a free market you can shop somewhere else. You don't have that choice in PA; it's the State Stores...or the State Police.

The State Store System does nothing for the citizens. It limits job creation, tax collection, selection, service, choice, and  entrepreneurial  drive of small businesses.  I think we can do far better: don't you?



END IT, DON'T MEND IT!

Thursday, August 6, 2015

Agency stores - How the Democrats will prove privatization doesn't work

In an August 5th interview with the Pittsburgh Tribune-Review, Democrat State Senator Jay Costa said he backed "agency shops" as a compromise to efforts by GOP legislators to privatize the State Store System. What he is really saying is, 'Let's show how these fail and keep the State Stores.' How do I know this?  Let's look at the scenario.
It's for all his friends in the rural areas.
First: The stores will only be put in underserved rural areas (you know, those 20 counties that have only one or two State Stores in hundreds of square miles), and he admits that it's to avoid cutting into PLCB profits from well-performing outlets in populous areas of the state. Nothing like a fair and level playing field for the suckers lucky entrepreneurs in those agency shops!

Second: Given the lack of enthusiasm for the "store in a store" concept (only fifteen in the whole state after 35 years!), it will probably be a standalone structure, forcing a higher cost per square foot than if integrated into an existing store. Even if not, the existing store would still legally have to provide separate entrance and register, increasing their cost. Of course, the hours won't be any better than the current State Stores either.

Third: "State Mandatory" items that all State Stores have to carry may not be the product mix these rural stores need to have, costing shelf space and sales. But Harrisburg knows best, so they're stuck.

Fourth: These stores will still have to buy from the PLCB. It isn't clear if they will get wholesale prices, which is highly unlikely (given the PLCB's jealously stingy attitude toward any private entities), or some discount from the PLCB retail price, like bars and restaurants do. If they do get a discount, you can be sure it won't be the same the State Stores get, thereby ensuring higher prices at the agency stores...exactly what the PLCB bureaucrats want to prove: private stores "cost more."

Fifth: Cost of transportation, while not stated, will certainly play a part. If you think the PLCB will provide free shipment to their new competition, you are just wrong — it ain't gonna happen.  That leaves the agency store going to a larger state store to pick up product, or all the way to one of three warehouses in the state.  (P.S. The PLCB is trying to knock that down to only two warehouses — more convenience!) In either case it is time and expense that the State Stores don't have to bear.

Sixth: While Ohio does have agency stores, that is ALL they have. There is no competing with State Stores, no limitations on being only in rural areas, and still no competition because the state sets the prices. They are a control state, just not as onerous as PA. Not a real improvement, by any stretch of the imagination.

Seventh: With a very limited number of these stores (no details on the amount, or what the criteria is for selection), there wouldn't be the incentive or need for any price competition that the free market brings. It would be the same as the beer distributor oligopoly, only with even more protections for maintaining a higher price.


So Senator Costa is selling us a bill of goods, and not an attractive one at all. What agency stores would really be about is three things.
  1. Like "modernization," putting in agency stores would lead directly to a cry to 'give them a chance,' which is really about kicking the privatization can down the road, putting it off so Wendell W. Young IV doesn't have to worry about it for another five years at least.
  2. Set up to fail, agency stores would be a great straw man for anti-privatization fanatics to point to and say, 'See, we gave you privately-owned stores, and what happened? The same selection (or less), higher prices, and no more convenience than the State Stores!!!" Because that's the way Costa wants it to be.
  3. The PLCB no longer has unprofitable stores. Because they'd dump all the stores that aren't making a profit — due to their ballooning operating costs — on the agency stores, allowing them to decrease the number of State Stores again, keeping their bloated payrolls and administrative costs humming along in markets where selling booze is like shooting fish in a barrel. 
We urge the GOP not to bite on this. Senator Costa is actually proposing to save the State Stores — a bad idea from the 1930s — with 'agency stores,' another bad idea from the 1930s. Don't double down on stupid.

Like we keep saying: End It, Don't Mend It. There's a great solution to the problems of the State Stores: privatization. Don't let this moment go. Don't let Governor Wolf off the hook.

Tuesday, August 4, 2015

"PLCB Modernization" means "PLCB higher prices"

Another installment in our ongoing series of revelations about why "modernization" is a scam.

We always hear about how the "PLCB Modernization" plans will make so much more for the state! But what they won't tell you is that they all work by taking more money out of your pocket. Here is one of sneaky little things they want to do that will cost you more. You don't see much about this item, as the PLCB has buried it pretty well. Well-hidden or not, it is one of their many ideas that will cost you, the consumer.
 
Because it's the PLCB way!
In the liquor industry there are specials that are offered called SPAs  or Special Purchase Allowances. By current law these SPAs have to be passed on to the consumer (that's you!), which is why you see  those sale tags on the shelves. The PLCB isn't making any less, as none of that reduction comes out of their pocket; they are just passing on the SPA.

However, the PLCB doesn't want to do that anymore. In sworn testimony, the PLCB said "With flexible pricing, the Board would be in a position to retain, and ultimately remit to the Commonwealth, some of the savings afforded by the Board's suppliers" In plain English? 'We aren't satisfied with making the exact same amount on sale items, we want to make more and have the citizens save less.' (I did a post last year about "flexible or variable pricing" if you want to review that.) In a worst case scenario, which is without a doubt what the PLCB will do, they could get an SBA, adjust the pricing upward and pocket 80-90% of the savings that were supposed to be yours.

Now, in the free market, a store will leverage those SPAs by not only using the reduction in their cost but by also cutting their margin to lower the price even further in order to attract customers away from other businesses. That is why sale prices elsewhere are more of a bargain than the sale prices in PA. The PLCB doesn't want to do that, though, because they need more money to cover their ever-expanding operating costs.

In 82 years, we have never seen anything done to change the liquor code to save you money. Benefiting the consumer is not what the Almighty Liquor Code is for, after all, unless it's about free drinks while playing slots. They have no problem with that.

It is time to END IT, not mend it. Get the state out of the alcohol business and into regulation where it belongs.






For parts 1-4 of this series see :
Part I,
Part II
Part III
Part IV 

Tuesday, June 30, 2015

HISTORY





For the first time a liquor privatization bill has passed the Senate. It took 82 years but there is light at the end of the tunnel for Pennsylvania consumers. While there is no guarantee a deal can be made with Governor Wolf the next election rotation looks good to increase the Republican majority enough to over ride his veto.  Perhaps by then he will be able to read the writing on the wall and do what most residents want.  Close the state store system.

Please don't forget to write your Legislators to thank them or to point out the folly of trying to hold on to the past.
END IT! DON'T MEND IT!

The ISSU decides the PLCB isn't so bad.(for the moment)


Our friends at the ISSU (Independent State Store Union, the union of the liquor store managers) have been fairly quite about privatization, I guess it is hard to side with the PLCB when you have said:

"The PLCB/industry makes a mockery of the control system for the common good when encouraging and incentivizing people...(4/13/11)"


"No other state in the country takes a more derelict approach to alcohol policy."

“With this announcement the PLCB continues to foster a climate of increasing consumption which is incongruent with their responsibility to establish policies intended to minimize the harms of alcohol (4/28/11)"

These were pretty good too:

"And, in pursuit of their delusional effort as a wannabe “world class retailer" , they have also implemented multi-million dollar advertising campaigns for the promotion of alcohol sales" (12/9/11)

"In their lust to act as a ‘world-class retailer,’ the current management with the PLCB has denigrated all past and present employees..."(6/21/11)

"The schizophrenic model of the current PLCB Board and management is anathema to reasonable control and responsible alcohol policy."(6/21/11)

I'm sure if you said the same about your boss you might be looking for a new job.

So in only the third press release in the past few years about privatization the ISSU decided it was better to protect their jobs then to continue to tell the PLCB they are incompetent and came out with the following.  I'll inject some comments as you read it.

SOS...how appropriate.


This may be your last chance to voice your opposition to the bill to your elected officials. Call your state senator and state representative NOW and tell them to vote NO on House Bill 466!

June 29, 2015
In an attempt to provide additional revenue for the 2015-2016 budget, the Senate is poised to consider a bill that would divest the state of the current liquor store system. While it has been widely stated that the current liquor privatization plan will generate an additional $220 million for the General Fund, one aspect of the plan has not received nearly as much publicity - where the additional $220 million comes from.

The simple and honest answer is from the pockets of consumers through higher shelf prices on liquor and wine.

As Senator McIlhinney pointed out Sunday morning on the CBS 21 news show Face the State and again Sunday evening in a Senate Law and Justice Committee meeting, we cannot divest the current liquor system, maintain current revenue and generate an additional $220 million without expecting the cost of liquor and wine to increase dramatically.

So much for the promise of "better prices" under a privatized system as promised by privatization advocates over the last four years of this debate.

Like other retail items you buy, every single one in fact, the price is not the same everywhere.  Mr. Troyan somehow forgot to mention the license fees, business taxes, increased employment, increased sales and reduced border bleed due to greater convenience, the reducing of public debt and the lease of the wholesale business in his letter....I wonder why? All those revenue streams don't exist under modernization and those supporters claimed they could get an extra $185 million without those revenue streams so is $220 million that far fetched?

The PLCB operates on an effective 45.2% markup so that does leave room for profit in a private setting. Will you pay the same for a bottle of JD at a smaller local store as you would at a larger liquor store? I doubt it, but then you pay more for milk in a convenience store than a grocery store too.  Same idea here.


Since the current privatization plan being considered by the Senate will increase the number of establishments selling wine and liquor for off-premise consumption from 600 to nearly 14,000, product selection will suffer as well. Very few of those 14,000 locations will stock the number of items available at the current state stores. The number of outlets will dictate that the overwhelming majority of retailers will limit their stock to the top ten or twenty items.

So, there goes the second major promise - better selection - that privateers have used to win public approval of their privatization efforts.

If only 5% of all stores stock more than the state stores we will still be better off (5% of 14,000 is 700 and the state only has 605 stores now) You can be assured that real superstores will want your business, stores that have more items on the shelf than the entire state does now. Of course not everyplace will have that anymore than every town has a Jaguar dealer. Consumer demand will decide not a bureaucrat in Harrisburg.

That leaves "convenience" as the only remaining argument to justify the divestiture of the current liquor system. Under this plan, "convenience" translates into 14,000 locations offering only the top ten or twenty products at highly inflated prices.

Are your constituents willing to pay the cost for this so-called "convenience"?
Pennsylvania already has the cleanest and safest liquor stores that carry a greater selection at a cheaper price than nearly all other privatized states.

While I know Mr. Troyan is trying to make a point he isn't doing a very good job. Having one place to buy beer,wine and spirits is only "so called" convenience to him for some reason  How many different soft drinks are in your local store? What is a larger seller, wine or soda and which has a higher margin? Do you really think stores will only have 20 items? Just something to think about.

Since PA is the second largest purchaser of wine and spirits in the US  for retail (8th for wholesale) one would think we would have the best prices but here is Mr. Troyan admitting that some private states do better. Maybe not entire states but certainly there are stores surrounding PA that do better on a regular basis. He apparently hasn't been to a Total Wine, Joe Canal's, Moore Brothers, State Line, Binny's, BevMo or a raft of others across the country that have more selection than any 2 PA stores put together. Some are even larger than any 2 state stores put together.


Please OPPOSE HOUSE BILL 466 and efforts to privatize and divest the current state store system.
Sincerely,
Michael A. Troyan, President
Independent State Store Union

Lastly, Mr. Troyan forgot one thing.  GOVERNMENT SHOULD NOT BE IN RETAIL AND ATTEMPT TO REGULATE THEIR COMPETITION AT THE SAME TIME.

People should be able to choose what they want and not have the state choose for them. Contact your legislators and tell them to support liquor freedom.

Monday, June 15, 2015

PA House Democrats drank the PLCB Kool-Aid

Thinking the Democrats in the PA Legislature might suddenly, somehow come to their senses on normalization of the PLCB? Forget it. All the quotes below are taken from the PA House Democratic website. It seems that they have their own way of looking at things that may or may not match reality. Let's take a peek.

Facts?  Nobody posts facts on the internet!
"By modernizing and increasing convenience for customers, the stores would generate at least $125 million more per year once the changes are fully phased in."

That extra $125 million, even if possible, has to come from someplace and that place is you the PA consumer. Since they only make about that now with the prices they charge, how do you think they will double it? As for convenience, the number of stores has decreased by 25% since 1970, from over 750 to 605, and 7% of that loss is since 2010. Ask the people with only one or two stores in their entire county how convenient the state store system is.

"Recently, privatization in other states has brought higher prices and reduced selection in grocery stores."

There is only one state that "recently" privatized: Washington in 2012. Anyplace else was over 25 years ago and can hardly be called "recent" in my opinion.  So privatization brought reduced selection in grocery stores. Well, we can guarantee that won't happen in Pennsylvania, since they won't let us buy wine or spirits in grocery stores now! As for the higher prices, that's due to the higher taxes and fees that were imposed at the same time as privatization: can't blame that on the stores, that's just the greedy government. Don't want higher prices? Simple: don't raise the taxes!

Even if we look at states that did privatize 25 years ago we find that according to the PFM report and the State of Iowa itself -- they made more money. To quote the report, "Privatization was deemed successful from a revenue standpoint, with profits increasing by $125 million over the first 11 years of privatization compared to estimates under State control of the stores." For West Virginia it is said that not every county has a liquor store since they privatized and while that is true, NOBODY in West Virginia has to drive as far as some residents of Pennsylvania do. Let me say that again - NOBODY.

"In some communities, privatization would lead to the opening of more liquor stores, while in more rural areas, consumers might not have access to a liquor store without driving out of their way."

Again using Washington, only one of 39 counties has less liquor stores now than they did before privatization and even that county still has a liquor store. As far as driving out of their way, I guess that is subjective since the House Democrats don't think a round trip of 75 miles is "out of their way" as this citizen does. Perhaps the two years the people of Mountaintop had to wait for a store to reopen in the same shopping center wasn't an inconvenience either. More liquor stores means more convenience. Of course there will be more liquor stores! Pennsylvania has one of the lowest store densities in the entire world, outside of countries like Saudi Arabia where alcohol is literally illegal. We have been under-served for decades.

"PA Wine and Spirits stores carry 30,000 products, with an average of 3,000 in stock at any time. The stores provide or support 4,000 family sustaining jobs in every county in Pennsylvania."

Not to get too much into semantics, but if you have a product on a list -- that you don't control -- that just means it MAY be available in your system. There are private stores with 11,000 wine and spirits in stock, on the shelves, more products than in the entire state of Pennsylvania, and they can (and happily will) special order things too. There are none in Pennsylvania, of course, but they are easy enough to find. Just look across our borders. As for the jobs, over a third of all PLCB employees are part time and that isn't a "family sustaining" job. That leaves about 3,000 full time employees and not all of them work in the stores or support the stores so that 4,000 number is certainly high. The PFM report doesn't agree with it either. In any case, the states and provinces that have fully privatized tripled employment in the industry.

State Store Motto

And finally in an outright lie they finish up with:

"A June 2014 poll by Franklin & Marshall showed that more than half of the people questioned (57%) said they preferred to modernize the State Wine and Spirit Stores, rather than sell them off."

Too bad that the real number is 32% as shown on page 16 of the poll.  BTW, it went down in the March 2015 poll too. There has never been a scientific poll that shows the people want to keep the state stores, not once, not ever in 80 years. Maybe because we don't want the state store system and never have.

END IT, DON'T MEND IT.

Tuesday, May 12, 2015

Revealed: How the PLCB is going to make that extra $185 million...

Well...they aren't. Nobody really believes that the "Consortium of Control States" is going to work; states just won't work together on booze sales. That puts a big hole in the total right off the bat.  Using the 6.92% profit margin for the PLCB that has been bandied about by some legislators -- which is optimistic, at best --  the state would have to sell over $1.3 Billion in additional product — an increase of over 50% — in the next two years to hit the revenue goals in "modernization." In other words, they want to take more money from you in increased sales, fees, and higher prices.(We break it down for you here.) Not exactly how most people think of "control."

The only way the PLCB "makes" more money is by taking it from YOU

Tell your legislators that is it time they did something FOR the people, and not TO the people. Free us from 80 years of incompetence, mismanagement, graft, idiocy, nepotism, and political payback by making Pennsylvania normal again. Let the state regulate, not retail. Or as some genius on the PennLive site recently commented: 

"End it, don't mend it."






Thursday, April 23, 2015

Why is it that....


The PLCB advertises even though they have no competition. There is no such thing as shopping for the best price; there's only the PLCB price. And of course...forget about shopping for selection. If they don't have it, you don't need it. Or want it. You may think you do...but they think better.

The PLCB limits how many bars and restaurants can serve alcohol, and while very few places are under their quota, there isn't a quota for State Stores. We are nowhere near what a normal state would have for liquor stores (and normal for wine retailers is so far away we can't even see it from here). In fact, the number of State Stores has been steadily decreasing for the past 45 years from over 750 to the current 605, and has only held steady the past two years.

The PLCB has no paper trail that lists who came up with in-house brands, who made the decision to feature them on endcaps, who decided to push them in advertising, and who said to feature them as alternatives when doing searches on the website? Do they know what they are doing at all? (Does any of it have to do with the continuing trail of ethics violations?)

The PLCB never lists any proof for the sales increases "modernization" supposedly will bring. Tell us exactly how opening another 140 stores on Sunday will generate $22 million more in operating income, or how just opening stores quicker will add $25 million more? Tell us what states will join in the booze-buying consortium being proposed? Have they even been approached about it? (Wanna bet there's no paper trail?) Tell us how the PLCB will make $75 million more if allowed to set pricing? Who will decide what the pricing will be, what will the change be based on, who will have oversight, who will look out for the consumer's interest (it never has been the folks in Harrisburg so don't expect them to suddenly start now),

The PLCB hasn't said whether a six-bottle container of 750ml bottles of Belgian Trappist brew will be a "case" too under their new "interpretation." It is over 144 ounces after all.  What about 6 bottles of beer that are only available in 700 ml bottles? Will there be a special "interpretation" for those if somebody decides to sue and the PLCB is too lazy to support their 80 years of apparently wrong "interpretation" like what happened in the latest "interpretation" that allowed 12 packs? And why can't the Legislature get off its butt and just do away with the case law entirely?

The PLCB ranks 15th worst out of 17 control states for binge drinking rates and is in the bottom half of all states, tied for 31st place. Why? Because "control states" like PA don't really control anything. The total alcohol use for control states averages higher (2.46 gallons per capita consumption in gallons, based on population age 14 and older) than the U.S. average of 2.33.

The PLCB's plans to increase sales are "good," but if the system were normalized, and a retailer wanted to increase alcohol sales...that would then be "bad?" Is private alcohol chemically different from PLCB alcohol? It's the same tax rate.

The PLCB and its pitiful handful of supporters somehow manage to overcome all of these issues, and continue to monopolize liquor and wine sales in the commonwealth. Kinda makes you wonder what keeps the Legislature from cleaning this up.